Manhaj Ta‘lil Percanggahan Riwayat Hadis Oleh Ibn Hazm Al-Andalusiy Dalam Al-Muhalla
Ibn Hazm al-Andalusiy’s Ta‘lil Methods for Contradicting Hadis Narrations in al-Muhalla
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.33102/johs.v8i2.260Keywords:
Ibn Hazm al-Andalusiy, al-Muhalla, ta‘lil methods, contradictions in the narrations of hadisAbstract
Ibn Hazm al-Andalusiy was an eminent Muslim scholar. Nevertheless, he was not free of criticism. Among the criticisms levelled at him was that he had not determined the defects (ta‘lil) for many conflicting hadis narrations like most other hadis scholars had. Thus, this paper aims to analyse his ta‘lil methods (manhaj) for contradicting hadis narrations in his work, al-Muhalla. This qualitative research is carried out using the literature review method. The data obtained was then analysed based on inductive and deductive methods. The findings of the study show that some of Ibn Hazm's methods to determine the defects in conflicting hadis narrations are in line with most hadis scholars, such as rejecting the element of insertion (idraj) in the text of hadis and refraining (tawaqquf) from making decisions for narrations containing discrepancies (idtirab). On the other hand, some of his methods in this matter were found to be in contradiction with the views of the majority of hadis scholars, such as rejecting allegations that reliable (thiqah) narrators could make mistakes and accepting additions (ziyadah) from credible narrators. This shows that he had his own method for determining the defects in conflicting hadis narrations.
Downloads
References
Abu H}a>tim, Ibn H}ibba>n. 1973. Al-Thiqa>t. India: Da>’irah al-Ma‘a>rif al-‘Uthma>niyyah.
Abu> Su‘ayli>k, Muh}ammad ‘Abd Alla>h. 1995. Al-Ima>m Ibn H}azm al-Z}a>hiriy: Ima>m Ahl al-Andalus. Beirut: Da>r al-Qalam.
Al-Alba>niy, Na>s}ir al-Di>n. 1992. Silsilah al-Ah}a>di>th al-D}a‘i>fah wa al-Mawd}u>‘ah. Riyadh: Da>r al-Ma‘a>rif.
‘Aliy, T}a>ha>. 2001. Al-Manhaj al-H}adi>thiy ‘Inda al-Ima>m Ibn H}azm al-Andalusiy. Beirut: Da>r Ibn H}azm.
Ameruddin Khalil & Mohd Muslim (t.t.) Ibn Hazm: Satu Tinjauan Terhadap Biografi dan Sumbangannya. Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia: Fakulti Pengajian Islam.
Al-Andalusiy, Ibn H}azm. t.t.. Al-Muh}alla> bi al-A>tha>r. Beirut: Da>r al-Fikr.
Al-‘Asqala>niy, Ah}mad. 1986. Taqri>b al-Tahdhi>b. tahqiq Muh}ammad ‘Awa>nah. Syria: Da>r al-Rashi>d.
Al-‘Asqala>niy, Ah}mad. 1908. Tahdhi>b al-Tahdhi>b, India: Mat}ba‘ah Da>’irah al-Ma‘a>rif al-Niz}a>miyyah.
Al-Baghda>diy, Ibn Sa‘d. 1990. Al-T}abaqa>t al-Kubra>, tahqiq Muh}ammad ‘Abd al-Qa>dir ‘At}a>. Beirut: Da>r al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyyah.
Al-Bayhaqiy, Abu Bakr. 2003. Al-Sunan al-Kubra>. Tahqiq oleh Muh}ammad ‘Abd al-Qa>dir ‘At}a>. Beirut: Da>r al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyyah.
Al-Bazza>r, Abu Bakr. 2009. Musnad al-Bazza>r, tahqiq oleh Mah}fu>z} al-Rah}man Zayn Allah. Madinah: Maktabah al-‘Ulu>m wa al-H}akm.
Al-Bukha>riy, Muh}ammad. 2001. S}ah}i>h} al-Bukha>riy. tahqiq Muh}ammad Zuhayr bin Na>s}ir al-Na>s}ir. Beirut: Da>r T}u>q al-Naja>h.
Al-Da>raqut}niy, ‘Ali. 1985. Al-‘Ilal al-Wa>ridah fi> al-Ah}a>di>th al-Nabawiyyah. tahqiq Mah}fu>z} al-Rah}man Zayn Allah, Riyadh: Da>r T}aybah.
Al-Da>raqut}niy, ‘Ali. 1984. Su’a>la>t al-H}a>kim al-Naysa>bu>riy li al-Da>raqut}niy, tahqiq Muwaffaq bin ‘Abd Allah, Riyadh: Maktabah al-Ma‘a>rif.
Al-Dhahabiy, Shams al-Di>n. 1963. Mi>za>n al-I‘tidal, tahqiq ‘Ali Muh}ammad al-Baja>wiy. Beirut: Da>r al-Ma‘rifah li al-T}aba>‘ah wa al-Nashr.
Al-Dhahabiy, Shams al-Di>n. 1985. Siyar A‘la>m al-Nubala>’, tahqiq Shu‘ayb al-Arna’u>t} et al. Beirut: Mu’assasah al-Risa>lah.
Al-H}anafiy, Mughlat}a>y. 2001. Ikma>l Tahdhi>b al-Kama>l fi> Asma>’ al-Rija>l, tahqiq Abu ‘Abd al-Rah}man ‘A>dil bin Muh}ammad, 12 jilid, al-Fa>ru>q al-H}adi>thiyyah li al-T}aba>‘ah wa al-Nashr.
Al-H}ajja>j, Muslim. t.t.. S}ah}i>h} Muslim, tahqiq Muh}ammad Fu’a>d ‘Abd al-Ba>qiy, 5 jilid, Beirut: Da>r Ih}ya>’ al-Tura>th al-‘Arabiy.
Hamma>m, ‘Abd al-Razza>q. 1982. Al-Mus}annaf, tahqiq H}abi>b al-Rah}man al-A‘z}amiy, 11 jilid, Beirut: Al-Maktab al-Isla>miy.
H}anbal, Ah}mad. 2001. Musnad al-Ima>m Ah}mad bin H}anbal, tahqiq Shu‘ayb al-Arna’u>t et al. Beirut: Mu’assasah al-Risa>lah.
H}anbal, Ah}mad. 2001. Al-‘Ilal wa Ma‘rifah al-Rija>l, tahqiq Was}iy Allah bin Muh}ammad ‘Abba>s. Riyadh: Da>r al-Kha>niy.
Hudaya, Hairul. (2012). ‘Menguji Kompleksitas ‘Illah Hadis’, 11 (2), hlm 212. Akses daripada https://idr.uin-antasari.ac.id/6253.
Ibn al-S}ala>h}, Abu ‘Amr (2019). ‘Ulu>m al-H}adi>th li Ibn al-S}ala>h}. Beirut: Da>r al-Fikr al-Ma‘a>s}ir.
Ibn ‘Asa>kir, ‘Ali. 1995. Ta>ri>kh Dimashq, tahqiq ‘Amr bin Ghawa>mah al-‘Umariy, Da>r al-Fikr li al-T}aba>‘ah wa al-Nashr wa al-Tawzi>‘.
Ibn Fa>ris, Ah}mad. 1979. Mu‘jam Maqa>yi>s al-Lughah, Beirut: Da>r al-Fikr.
Ibn al-Jama>‘ah, Badr al-Di>n. (1406H). Al-Manhal al-Ra>wiy fi Mukhtas}ar ‘Ulu>m al-H}adi>th al-Nabawiy. Damsyik: Da>r al-Fikr.
Ibn Ma‘i>n, Yah}ya>. 1985. Ma‘rifah al-Rija>l ‘an Yah}ya> bin Ma‘i>n. Damsyik: Majma‘ al-Lughah al-‘Arabiyyah.
Ibn Ma>jah, Muh}ammad. t.t.. Sunan Ibn Ma>jah. tahqiq Muh}ammad Fu’a>d ‘Abd al-Ba>qiy, T.T.P.: Da>r Ih}ya>’ al-Kutub al-‘Arabiy.
Ibn Sa‘d, Muh}ammad. 1990. Al-T}abaqa>t} al-Kubra>, tahqiq Muh}ammad ‘Abd al-Qa>dir ‘At}a>. Beirut: Da>r al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyyah.
Ibn Sha>hi>n, ‘Umar. 1984. Ta>ri>kh Asma>’ al-Thiqa>t, tahqiq S}ubh}iy al-Sa>mara>’iy. Kuwait: al-Da>r al-Salafiyyah.
Al-‘Ira>qiy, Zayd al-Di>n. 1969. Al-Taqyi>d wa al-I>d}a>h} Sharh} Muqaddimah Ibn al-S}ala>h}, tahqiq ‘Abd al-Rah}man Muh}ammad ‘Uthma>n, Madinah: Muh}ammad ‘Abd al-Muh}sin al-Kutubiy S}a>h}ib al-Maktabah al-Salafiyyah.
‘Itr, Nu>r al-Di>n. 1979. Manhaj al-Naqd fi> ‘Ulu>m al-H}adi>th, Damsyik: Da>r al-Fikr.
Al-Jurja>niy, Ibn ‘Adiy. 1997. Al-Ka>mil fi> al-D}u‘afa>’ al-Rija>l. tahqiq ‘A>dil Ah}mad ‘Abd al-Mawju>d, Beirut: al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyyah.
Al-Khat}t}a>biy, Abu Sulayma>n. 1932. Ma‘a>lim al-Sunan. Halab: al-Mat}ba‘ah al-‘Alamiyyah.
Al-Malyaba>riy, H}amzah ‘Abd Allah. 1997. Al-H}adi>th al-Ma‘lu>l Qawa>‘id wa D}awa>bit}. Beirut: Da>r Ibn H}azm.
Al-Mizziy, Jama>l al-Di>n. 1980. Tahdhi>b al-Kama>l fi> Asma>’ al-Rija>l. tahqiq Basha>r ‘Awa>d Ma‘ru>f. Beirut: Mu’assasah al-Risa>lah.
Mohd Aizul Yaakob & Roshimah Shamsudin. 2022. Al-Tafarrud dan Hubungannya dengan ‘Illah Menurut Sarjana Hadis. Pulau Pinang: Pernerbit Universiti Sains Malaysia.
Al-Nasa>’iy, Ah}mad. 1986. Al-Mujtaba> min al-Sunan, tahqiq ‘Abd al-Fatta>h} Abu Ghuddah. Halab: Maktab al-Mat}bu>‘a>t al-Isla>miyyah.
Al-Nasa>’iy, Ah}mad. 2001. Al-Sunan al-Kubra>, tahqiq H}asan ‘Abd al-Mun‘im, Beirut: Mu’assasah al-Risa>lah.
Al-Naysa>bu>riy, Al-H}a>kim. 1977. Ma‘rifah ‘Ulu>m al-H}adi>th, tahqiq al-Sayd Ma‘z{am H}usayn, Beirut: Da>r al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyyah.
Al-Ra>ziy, Ibn Abi H}a>tim. 1952. Al-Jarh} wa al-Ta‘di>l, Beirut: Da>r Ih}ya>’ al-Tura>th al-‘Arabiy.
Al-Sa‘d, ‘Abd Allah. 2015. Kayfa Taku>n Muh}additha>, Riyadh: Da>r al-‘Ida>wah.
Al-T}abara>niy, Abu al-Qa>sim. t.t.. Al-Mu‘jam al-Awsat}, tahqiq T}a>riq bin ‘Awd} Allah. Kaherah: Da>r al-H}aramayn.
Al-T}abara>niy, Sulayma>n. t.t.. Al-Mu‘jam al-Kabi>r, tahqiq H}amdiy bin ‘Abd al-Maji>d. Kaherah: Maktabah Ibn Taymiyyah.
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
The copyright of this article will be vested to author(s) and granted the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license, unless otherwise stated.
Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work.
